And.The.Roo

The things you own end up owning you…

My first dive into the Ubuntu world

So, I’ve finally taken the plunge into the linux world with Ubuntu, after countless hours of XP maintenance throughout the years and who knows how many restarts/spyware scans. I’ve been an avid Windows user since the start, back in the 3.1 days until now, and have never really been satisfied with the level of quality Microsoft provides its users. I’ve played around a little with Tiger as well, but haven’t yet invested in an apple computer due to the lack of software support currently available for my needs. What can I say, I love my games and I’ve got a great system to run them on, so there’s no use in me spending $1000+ on another great system, when all I really want is the security structure of the OS that Tiger provides. That’s where Linux comes in.

I’ve been hearing more and more about how Linux, specifically Ubuntu, is heading for mainstream use because if how easy it is to operate, and how secure it is as well. So I said to myself “Okay, so here is a completely secure OS with great bundled software and features, a great support community, and above all, it’s FREE! What am I waiting for?” Next step, I download both Kubuntu and Ubuntu LiveCD’s, as I’d like to check out both Gnome and KDE to see which I prefer as opposed to the Windows desktop. The Ubuntu online resources are great, and it took no time at all to find the correct build to set up on my 64-bit system. Other than the dead link on the Kubuntu LiveCD download page, it was fairly easy to get started. Hopefully they’ve fixed that, but if not there’s multiple sources for US downloads from their website, so it wasn’t a big deal.

As far as how easy it is to actually install, that’s exactly what it was. Easy. I was skeptical at first because I’ve heard in the past how much a mess the installation process can be, but to my surprise it was actually much more simple compared to an XP install. I put the disc in, rebooted, and within a few minutes I was looking at a nice clean desktop with an install icon in the top left. I played around with the desktop a little, and here’s a few things I noticed:

 

1. The desktop is simply beautiful with Gnome. I would definitely recommend it over KDE, but ultimately it’s up to the users choice. I couldn’t have asked for more (Xgl, anyone?). It’s easy to navigate and find what you need with no problems at all. I actually prefer the interface over the XP interface, with the top and bottom panels providing everything I need for easy access. Plus, it just looks better. It had a more ‘vector’ feel to it than anything I’ve seen in XP. Everything was shiny, polished and nice J

2. One problem I had from the get-go was the OS wasn’t recognizing my USB keyboard. In fact, neither Kubuntu or Ubuntu recognized all 4 USB ports on the motherboard, so I had to switch a few things around to get both the keyboard and mouse working at the same time. So, I’m stuck for now with only 2 USB ports. I’m not sure what was causing this, probably a driver issue, so I tried installing the OS at this point to see if a full install would give the necessary driver support for the USB ports. Unfortunately, it did not, so I’m only stuck with the 2 ports at the time. If anyone has any suggestions, shoot me an email. I’m running a Gigabyte GA-8N-SLI board, not sure if they have any Linux drivers but I’ll be sure and check later on.

3. After installation, the system ran smooth as silk. It’s amazing how slow you realize XP runs with all those pointless applications running in the background, compared to how Ubuntu was running on my machine. It really is like black and white.

4. I was surprised at how many applications were installed by default. Everything you need is right there, whether it’s word processing (OpenOffice) or internet browsing (Firefox). It’s all just there. And whatever isn’t there, you can usually find what you need in the repository. I would have liked to see some out of box DVD or MP3 support, but that’s not a huge setback since you can get that support elsewhere. Overall, I would recommend its built in software over Windows indefinitely. The only problem I ran into was installing software. It took a bit of work just to get the correct driver package for the display up and running on the machine. You might want to do some research on the different package handlers and how to go about installing applications within Ubuntu before actually installing the OS, just a heads up.

 

So, overall I would say that I’m not quite ready to give up XP, but I’m definitely on the way. Ubuntu has such a large community for support that if you run into any problems, you’re pretty much covered. Although the OS can be quite technical when you start to dig deep, it should be easy enough for the average user to stick the CD in and go. I’m looking forward to getting more familiar with Ubuntu over time, and quite possibly scraping XP altogether for daily use (except for games, of course), as it is such a robust OS with much more out-of-box features than what Redmond has to offer. I’ll be looking more into the security integration of Ubuntu in the future, as well as the desktop features that KDE has to offer, so stay tuned!

Digg this story

 

- Roo

17 Comments »

  Joseph wrote @

It would appear that most versions of Linux lack in the ability to detect USB products..
It would not detect my USB keyboard either..
Thats not enough of a setback for me though..
I will always be a fan of Linux as it has many features to keep someone busy for a long time..

  Joseph wrote @

Oh.. and thanks for the very informative review..
It was a pleasure reading your thoughts on this wonderful OS..

  Declan Elliott wrote @

Andrew if you have not heard about it yet checkout automatix – http://www.getautomatix.com/ – it auto installs all the multi media drivers and codecs you might need as well as a multitude of other goodies – just select all packages – it takes an hour to install and you have to be around to plug in your password occasionally but is worth the time very handy for newbies to linux – of which I’m one.

  Joe wrote @

1) Ubuntu being more secure than XP is a myth. According to Secunia, Ubuntu 6.06 has had 29 advisories this year compared to 26 for XP Professional. And, Ubuntu hasn’t even been available for the whole year.

2) About the numerous applications running in the background on XP as you claim, you should blame your hardware vendor for that and not the OS. Dell and other vendors install lots of crap that run in the tray. If you perform your own clean installation of XP from the original CD, you will find that the OS runs snappily without all the bloatware that the vendors install.

  UbuWu wrote @

Joe, about security: XP professional currently has 28 unpatched vulnerabilities, compared to 0 for Ubuntu 6.06. Some of these are classified as highly critical by Secunia.

  awray wrote @

Joe – While running windows fresh will give a much more pleasing response as far as windows goes, there are much more default background applications running as opposed to Ubuntu by default. Comparing the performance and overall response time on the same-spec’d machine definately shows Ubuntu coming out on top. It has a more “snappy” feel to it. As far as the bloatware, it’s a custom built machine by myself. I like to know exactly what’s going on with my systems, so there aren’t too many running processes during regular use and no unnecessary unused running applications. It may just be a personal preference, but Ubuntu definately responds better than XP on any system in my opinion. Not once did I see my HDD light crazily flashing for no reason, when there was no activity on the computer, while using Ubuntu. You get that alot when Windows is trying to figure out what to do, or when one of the background processes takes up system resources, independent on whether or not there is spyware or bloatware installed on an XP machine. Just something I noticed…

  ArsGeek wrote @

Just found your article via digg and had a good time reading it. It’s great to see someone with lots of Windows experience enjoying an open source OS as well.

I still dual boot my primary machine (an IBM x60 laptop) becasue I enjoy playing some games that Linux just doesn’t support. That and I need to use some MS office apps for a few classes I’m taking (sigh).

I second the call to check out Automatix, it simplifies a lot of the install process for 3rd party codecs and various software from RAR to Google Earth.

Have fun with Ubuntu!
ArsGeek

  Nequeo wrote @

You actually might see your HDD lights flashing wildly in Ubuntu, but it’s probably just the ‘locate’ database being rebuilt, or an ‘apt-get update’ being run in the background by the update-notifier. It will probably happen around midnight, or whenever you first boot up if you’ve had your PC off for over a day. Doesn’t take long.

You sound like you’re cluey enough you might have already known/figured this out – but take a peek into the /etc/cron.* directories. For example, in /etc/cron.daily are scripts that will run once a day. It’s nice to be able to see clearly what your operating system wants to run when.

I’m also quite fond of Ubuntu’s ’shot-gun’ approach to hardware detection. AFAIK, hardware is detected at boot and the required drivers/kernel modules loaded as needed. I recently replaced my motherboard and video card in one hit. Windows spat the dummy, demanded reactivating, and spent 40 or so minutes ‘detecting and installing new hardware’. Then I needed to reinstall the nVidia drivers and run the setup program on the mobo CD before. It did eventually come back to life, though. But Ubuntu booted straight back up without a pause, requiring absolutely zero reconfiguration to take advantage of the new hardware.

  mp wrote @

To address your usb issues:

Verify which type of ports don’t work. If they are USB 2.0, the right kernel module might not be loaded.

Otherwise:
1. open kterminal, type dmesg | grep acpi and see if there are any errors during boot time. You might check dmesg | grep apic or lapic and see if there are any messages.
2. On one of the “bad” ports, insert then remove a device.
3. Run dmesg | tail and see if there’s any messages about the insertion event. The other place to look is cat /var/log/messages | tail (do this as sudo) on the terminal. You should see some events there to help you sort it out.

From there, you will need to pass some kernel parameters during boot time.

1. sudo nano /boot/grub/boot.lst in the terminal and experiment with acpi=noirq in the kernel line.
2. update-grub hd0 (or is it grub-update hd0?) You are telling grub to update the MBR with your new settings. (I’m assuming you are using grub on your root partition)

If that doesn’t help, some other options to try: noapic pci=bios. I don’t exactly know what these settings do, but experimenting with them fixed some of my problems.

I suggest http://www.linuxquestions.org or Ubuntu’s message boards for help.

  mp wrote @

Joe,

As a Windows/Linux Server/XP desktop sysadmin in a higher-than-average security climate, you need to reexamine your beliefs because they just aren’t true.

A bare-bones XP or server install has a number things running at Administrator priviledges. What makes matters worse, is most of them -require- Admin priv’s to run. This is simply bad security policy and it’s only one small example of an OS with security provided as an afterthought. This is not acceptable any more.

I’m not saying Linux rulez. I’m saying it’s an excellent tool for many IT jobs. Some of which include desktop use.

Please, step away from the rhetoric a bit and examine the issues with a little more objectivity there’s some great stuff on Linux. It’s worth looking at.

[...] Check out the small review located here Posted by yourdailydose Filed in Linux [...]

  David Gypsy wrote @

Nice review! To the unbiased and informed, Linux is a very viable alternative, with none of the self-destructing qualities of windows.

  chris wrote @

Hi installed UBUNTU on my Dell inspiron 600 within 6 mins up and running wireless OK interactive buttons for sound and web surfing OK downloaded real player 10 for my web browser plugin upgrade e mail software to Novel evolution ,installed Picasa for photo’s ,Amarok for my music,Kmymoney for my personal accounts and HEY with all the other software that came with UBUNTU I have a brilliant system GNOME of course take the plunge !!!!!!!!!!!!

  fredericthewise wrote @

I’ve been running ubuntu for about 2 years (since 5.10) and if it keeps getting better at the rate it has so far it will be an exceptional platform into the future.

  Sherri wrote @

Hey, well I just recently switched from XP pro to Ubuntu. I love Ubuntu 10 times better, ( Problem is) none of my lanquage games run on it with sound. I have wine installed of course and the programs begin then stop or freez up. I get some sound, its a matter of patienc waiting to get help in the forums but not all their advice works, found that out to. I know they give there all so I truly respect that. I am frustrated at this point, thankfully I have XP on another PC, just not in my office space. I have ventured to look into going back to XP. One reason only, I do need my games and the sound, everything worked beautifully in XP, I was told they would work as well with Wine, well they do not. Outside of all this, I am sick to maybe have to return to windows, I may not have a choice.

Sherri

  O Ubuntu – SysInside wrote @

[...] Dharwadkar, PC World, Lunapark6, KnoLinux, GoTux!, Nepotismia, Mad Penguin, My Mind and I, IT Week, awray.wordpress.com, WhatPC, Extremetech, IT Reviews, The Jem Report, free-bees.co.uk, ASE Labs, Indigo Jo Blogs, [...]

  Ubuntu – SysInside wrote @

[...] Dharwadkar, PC World, Lunapark6, KnoLinux, GoTux!, Nepotismia, Mad Penguin, My Mind and I, IT Week, awray.wordpress.com, WhatPC, Extremetech, IT Reviews, The Jem Report, free-bees.co.uk, ASE Labs, Indigo Jo Blogs, [...]


Your comment

HTML-Tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>